Companies We Represent American Modern Claim # 800-375-2075 Billing # 800-543-2644 Pay Online Online Claim AmTrust Financial Claim # 888-760-9195 Billing # 844-447-5296 Pay Online Online Claim Encompass Insurance Claim # 800-588-7400 Billing # 866-430-2916 Pay Online Online Claim Grinnell Mutual Claim # Billing # 817-855-5500 Pay Online Online Claim The Hartford Claim # 800-252-4670 Billing # 800-426-9898 Pay Online Online Claim Liberty Mutual Insurance Claim # 833-218-0219 Billing # 866-324-8222 Pay Online Online Claim Progressive Claim # 877-672-6115 Billing # 800-877-0600, press 8 Pay Online Online Claim Rockford Mutual Claim # 800-588-7400 Billing # 866-430-2916 Pay Online Online Claim Resource Menu File a Claim/Make a Payment Policy Change Request Certificate of Insurance Request Form Add/Remove a Driver Add/Remove Vehicle to Auto Policy Refer a Friend Auto I.D. Card Request Form FAQ’s
